Someone needs to get a real job
Tuesday, August 28th, 2007News that a major stockholder was advocating the sale of Fleetwood Enterprises came as quite a shock to company executives gathered in Las Vegas Monday for the company’s annual dealer event. When someone who owns 11.8 percent of a company’s stock advocates the sale of that company on the same day corporate executives are traveling to meet with the very people who generate bundles of money for the firm, you’ve got to question the timing of such a suggestion.
Monday, New York City investment company SLS Management released a letter to the Fleetwood Board of Directors. Signed by Scott L. Swid, managing partner of the group, it advocated the sale of Fleetwood not just to the highest bidder, but to a specific company — Champion Enterprises. For those unfamiliar with the mobile home and modular housing industries, Champion is a key player in an industry losing money almost as fast as FEMA.
Here’s a quick financial snapshot for Champion Enterprises:
- 2006 = $1.36 billion in sales netted $43.1 million in profit (3.2 percent to the bottom line).
- 2005 = $1.27 billion in sales netted $45.5 million in profit (3.6 percent to the bottom line).
- 2004 = $1.01 billion in sales netted $17 million in profit (1.7 percent to the bottom line).
- 2003 = $1.14 billion in sales netted a $40 million loss (the last profitable year being 1999)
Fleetwood, by comparison, reported these results:
- 2006 = $2.01 billion in sales netted a $90 million loss
- 2005 = $2.43 billion in sales netted a $28.4 million loss
- 2004 = $2.37 billion in sales netted a $161.5 million loss
- 2003 = $2.36 billion in sales netted a $22.3 million loss
In other words, over the past four years, Fleetwood has logged $9.17 billion in sales compared to Champion’s $4.78 billion. But, Champion returned a profit of $65.6 million (1.4 percent of sales) while Fleetwood posted a $302.2 million loss. Okay, so Fleetwood has struggled a bit. But is Champion the model company SLS Management really wants the RV industry to emulate?
SLS Management produces nothing but financial statements and, apparently, letters to boards of directors for companies that don’t earn this freeloading firm enough money fast enough. Besides having contributed $4,600 to Hillary Clinton’s campaign so far this year, Swid’s job is similar to that of the Gordon Gekko character in the movie Wall Street. He also served on the finance and budget committee of the left-leaning Council on Foreign Relations, a group of “experts” who offer advice to government leaders (people elected to real jobs) on critical issues like the ”scant progress made for Afgahn women,” or who advocate that U.S. drug companies be denied patents for new life-saving medicines until they renounce those patent rights in poor countries.
According to an article that appeared in the Financial Times June 6, 2001, “SLS Investors is run by Scott Swid, whose father, Stephen Swid, was a pioneer in the leveraged buyout market. Hmmmm.
But Mr. Swid isn’t the key focus, SLS Management is. Perusing the Securities and Exchange Commission website, I had a chance to review SLS’s last few quarterly reports. Besides owning stock in Fleetwood, SLS also owns shares in Alcoa, Burger King, Citigroup, Comcast, Dell, E-Trade Financial, Ford, Gap, Herbalife, Kraft Foods, Macy’s, Motorola, Sandisk, Sears, Suntrust Bank, UAL, Wendy’s and a dozen others. So naturally, this company’s expertise clearly lies in the production and sale of recreation vehicles. (You can view SLS Management’s annual reports by clicking here.)
Digging deeper into the financial data, I discovered that SLS, despite losing money with Fleetwood, has consistently increased its shares of Fleetwood stock.
- June 30, 2004 = 494,199 shares
- Dec. 31, 2004 = 687,000 shares
- Dec. 31, 2005 = 3,774,501 shares
- Dec. 31, 2006 = 7,777,208 shares
- June, 30, 2007 = 7,588,590 shares
In fact, according to its June 2007 filing, SLS Management owns more shares of Fleetwood than it does any other company in its portfolio; Ford being second with 6.7 million shares and Lawson Software at 4.4 million shares.
But, during the same time, the company also acquired a number of shares in Champion.
- Dec. 31, 2006 = 518,872 total shares
- March 31, 2007 = 1,250,300 shares
- June 30, 2007 = 1,681,700 shares
So, in less than a year, SLS Management/Scott L. Swid have discovered Champion Enterprises, fallen in love with the company and tripled its investments in it. So enamored with Champion’s ability to generate $65.6 million in profit on $4.78 billion in revenue, SLS believes the Fleetwood board of directors should roll over and sell its $9.17 billion company to Champion.
Who stands to make the most money in this deal? Sounds like an attempt at market manipulation to me; and fiendish trick to play on Fleetwood on the eve of their dealer conference where several new brands and models will be announced. It makes me wonder if Scott L. Swid or SLS Management has an axe to grind with Fleetwood executives who will no doubt be ambushed at their dealer meeting by investors and others who have read Swid’s ridiculous recommendation, which you can view by clicking here.
Someone needs to get a job. As a shareholder in Burger King and Wendy’s I suggest that Mr. Swid start there.
Maybe if the company had ever manufactured something, we could take their recommendation seriously.
